The phrases sidereal and tropical are used to denote two alternative definitions of a year, which are employed in sidereal and tropical solar calendars, respectively. They refer to two alternative ecliptic coordinate systems used to split the ecliptic into twelve “signs” in astrology. A total of 360 degrees is created by dividing each sign into 30 degrees.
While sidereal astrology defines the signs in relation to the apparent backwards movement of fixed stars of about 1 degree every 72 years from the perspective of the Earth, tropical astrology defines 0 degrees of Aries to coincide with the vernal point or vernal equinox (also known as the March equinox in the Northern hemisphere) and the rest of the zodiac from this point.
To account for the observed precession of equinoxes, sidereal astrology uses correction techniques called as ayanamsas (Sanskrit: ‘ayana’ “movement” + ‘aa’ “component”) to keep signs and constellations aligned, whereas tropical astrology uses the Northern Hemisphere’s seasonal cycle. The two systems, which were formerly synchronized some 2,000 years ago, have drifted apart throughout the ages as a result of this.
The Lahiri ayanamsa and the Raman ayanamsa are two ayanamsa systems used in Hindu astrology (also known as Vedic astrology). In Western sidereal astrology, the Fagan-Bradley ayanamsa is an example of an ayanamsa system. Sun signs measured using the Sri Yukteswar ayanamsa were 23 degrees behind tropical sun signs as of 2020. People born between March 12 and April 12 would have the Pisces sun sign, according to these calculations. According to tropical calculations, anyone born between March 21 and April 19 have the sun sign of Aries.
The genesis of the zodiac, according to Cyril Fagan, a Western sidereal astrologer, was based on a notable conjunction that happened in 786 BC, when the vernal equinox was somewhere in mid-Aries, equating to a difference of 39 degrees or days.
In This Article...
What is the distinction between the tropical and sidereal zodiacs?
The tropical zodiac is based entirely on the sun, with the signs aligned with the ecliptic. The sidereal zodiac is determined by the sun’s position in reference to the constellations as seen in the night sky (measured in the early morning when the sun rises).
Is it more correct to use the Tropical or Sidereal calendar?
Different ecliptic coordinates differentiate Vedic or Sidereal astrology from Tropical or Western astrology. The Spring Equinox is defined in tropical astrology as the moment when the Sun enters the first degree of the sign Aries. The Sun enters Cancer at the Summer Solstice; the Sun enters Libra at the Autumn Equinox; and the Sun enters Capricorn at the Winter Solstice.
When we claim the Sun is in Leo, critics of astrology will argue that it is actually in Virgo. From the perspective of the earth, Western astrology does not consider the background of fixed stars to be a point of reference. Western astrology employs the same astronomical reference point as astronomy, dividing the ecliptic into parts beginning at the Vernal Equinox. As a result, measurements are transformed into coordinates that may be applied to any location in space. Astrology is designed to provide a mandala or photograph of the sky at birth from an immutable reference point, similar to the perspective of the soul.
Although these segments have the same names as the fixed star constellations, they are no longer in line with the constellations of the same name from an earth centered or Sidereal perspective due to the earth’s precession. The planets move through the constellations overhead like the planets move in Vedic or Sidereal astrology. Sidereal astrology cannot claim to be a more accurate or natural method than Tropical astrology because the constellations are not actually spaced in 30 degree segments. They’re merely two distinct ways of looking at astrology.
The seasonal equinoxes are flipped in the Southern latitudes, according to critics of Tropical astrology. Australia produces astrologers and even the most widely used astrology software. They utilize the Tropical orientation in their readings since it is more accurate.
Perhaps the Equinox and Solstice should not be given Northern seasonal names. The Equinox is the time when the Sun crosses the celestial equator for the second time in a year, thus it doesn’t matter if it’s the first day of Spring or the first day of Autumn. The Solstice is the time when the Sun rotates around its axis for the second time. These are the four Cardinal points or signals that simply dictate the placement of the other signs in the chart. We might remember that we’re working with metaphorical archetypes rather than actual star clusters if we used names like the Aries Equinox or the Capricorn Solstice.
Planetary positions move due to the earth’s precession, whereas Western astrologers adopt the Tropical approach as a fixed point in space. This webpage makes use of astronomical computations, the JPL ephemeris, and Vernal Equinox chart delineation.
Beyond reference points, there are other distinctions between Western and Vedic astrology. Each highlights a distinct approach to the chart, and knowing both can help you gain a better grasp of it.
What is the purpose of tropical astrology?
The astronomical phrases sidereal and tropical are used to represent two different conceptions of a “year.” They’re also the names of two ecliptic coordinate systems used in astrology. Both split the ecliptic into a number of “signs” named after constellations, but the sidereal system uses fixed stars to define the signs, whilst the tropical system uses the vernal equinox position. The two systems do not remain constant relative to each other due to equinox precession, but drift apart by around 1.4 arc degrees per century. During the Hellenistic period, the tropical system was adopted and is still used in Western astrology. In Hindu astrology and several Western astrology systems from the twentieth century, a sidereal system is used. While tropical astrology is concerned with the Earth’s location in relation to the Sun and planets of the solar system, sidereal astrology is concerned with the Earth’s position in relation to both of these as well as the stars of the celestial sphere. The horoscope also takes into account the actual locations of certain fixed stars as well as their constellations.
Which of the zodiac signs is the most accurate?
You might be hesitant to consult your rising sign daily horoscope if you’re a creature of habit who has long relied on your sun sign. According to astrologer and horoscope writer Mackenzie Greer, your rising sign is far more in sync with your real life and all of its complexity, which is why learning how to interpret your rising sign is worthwhile.
“Reading for your rising sign provides your horoscopes a level of precision that sun signs can’t match.” Astrologer Mackenzie Greer
“People frequently object to this advice, believing that their sun sign is the only truth,” Greer says. “However, the problem with that approach is that accurate sun sign horoscopes are, technically speaking, big-picture orientedthey’re not fine-tuned to the nitty-gritty details of the here and now.” “Because your rising sign decides where all the houses or sectors of life are built up in your birth chart, reading for your rising sign offers your horoscopes a dead-on accuracy that you just can’t obtain from sun signs,” says the author.
Is there any truth to sidereal astrology?
We know that Vedic astrology adjusts the signs for precession, whereas Western astrology preserves every sign at the same time of year regardless of the season. However, this does not imply that Vedic astrology is “more accurate” or that Western astrology “isn’t real.” Because, as we all know, astrology is all about the positions of the planets in the sky, not the signs. The tropical and sidereal zodiacs are both inaccurate in terms of astronomy. The constellations do not form a full 360o circle in the sky, and mostbut not allof the constellations closest to the ecliptic are explained by astrology (despite the reports, there is no 13th sign called Ophiuchus).
The tropical zodiac is more indicative of our material culture and society because it is linked to the seasons and the sun’s rising to summer and descend to winter throughout the year. The sun represents our ego, which tends to take precedence over everything else. The sidereal zodiac is more reflective of our soul’s journey and spiritual path because it corresponds to the stars and the wider backdrop of the cosmos. Neither is more correct than the other, and they both have valid points to make.
Which method of astrology is more reliable?
Between these two astrological forms, there is a variation in the house system. Vedic astrologers utilize whole-sign houses, with the Ascendant’s sign occupying the first house. The four angular houses (1st, 4th, 7th, and 10th) are known as kendras and are the seat of authority in Vedic astrology. The trikonas, on the other hand, hold the areas of good fortune and opportunity (1st, 5th, 9th).
All of these distinctions demonstrate that both of these types of astrology have their unique significance. Western astrology employs a distinct methodology, more akin to an open system, in which conventional procedures for preparing the birth chart are given less weight. Traditional methods, on the other hand, are the foundation of calculation and analogy in Vedic astrology. Because we can’t view the outer planets with our naked eyes, they aren’t utilised here. The best part about Vedic astrology is that planets are directly linked to energizing qualities like yoga, ayurveda, and a slew of other key spiritual assets in India.
Western astrology can produce bizarre results because astrologers here believe on the Sun sign, which is fixed for one month, as opposed to Vedic astrology, which emphasizes the Moon, which is fixed for 2.25 days. Let us have a look at how Vedic astrology differs from Western astrology.
Moon houses aren’t very important in Western Astrology. The Sun is the most important planet here, and its position is accorded great importance. The moon houses, on the other hand, are important in Vedic Astrology. In Vedic astrology, there are 27 Constellations. They are the most important factor in making time-related predictions. It is possible to learn about the finest times in life in order to establish a successful business, purchase a home, or perform ceremonies such as weddings, partnerships, or housewarmings. The Nakshatras are also useful for assessing a person’s characteristics and gaining a thorough understanding of their mental state. While Vedic astrology can provide more precise results by focusing on the moon, western astrology is unable to do so.
Horoscope matching is a valuable feature of Indian Vedic Astrology that has been utilized to determine the compatibility of a potential bride and groom before marriage since ancient times. Horoscope matching, also known as Kundli matching, is a wonderful present for a newlywed couple. The more traits (gunas) that match, the more compatible the bride and groom are. Horoscope matching can easily reveal two people’s potential to operate well together. Such information is not available in Western astrology. Though we can perform compatibility analysis using this method, the results will not be as exact as in Vedic astrology.
Nothing compares to the precision and profundity of Vedic Astrology. Western astrology can’t compete with the Vedic system’s deep levels of wisdom and insight. We employ nakshatras in Vedic astrology to refine the meaning and expression of the chart. The time-systems analyze the signals and themes of your current existence (dashas). There are dozens of aspects (Vargas) that can assist you in extracting the intricacies of every area of your life, from marriage to death, and from happy to terrible times. Western astrology, on the other hand, relies heavily on the sun for predictions and progression, which has rendered their method ineffective for many years.
Finding a good muhurta is highly crucial in Vedic astrology while starting any new work. Muhurta is the art of choosing the most auspicious time to achieve success in any endeavor you choose. By regularly studying the cosmic position for the window period to start something new or make any crucial decision, Vedic astrologers compute the auspicious moment. In western astrology, on the other hand, there is no such precise method for determining the optimal time to start a new business.
The composition, alignment, pace, and movement of the current transits are used to foretell the future in western astrology. Western astrology is not very good at predicting events; instead, it focuses on predicting changes in a person’s attitude or how the planets will affect his character. The current planetary phase, or shift in the position of the planets in a person’s birth chart, is used in Vedic astrology to forecast the future. As a result, each planet dominates your home for a specific amount of time. Interestingly, depending on the nature of the ruling planet, that time period might be favorable or harmful. For example, the Sun reigns for six years and Saturn reigns for nineteen. As a result, Vedic astrology’s future predictions are more precise and precise.
Because it is based on more exact astronomical principles, Vedic astrology appears to be more upright than western astrology. The best part about Vedic astrology is that the astrologers consider not just the natal chart but also the dasas, or periods of different planets travelling through different signs, and their impact on people’s lives. In addition, Vedic Astrology places a greater emphasis on the Moon sign than the Sun sign. The reason for this is that the Moon changes signs every 2.25 days, whereas the Sun takes around a month, so predictions based on the Moon are more accurate because our moods and circumstances change frequently. Second, because the moon governs the mind and emotions, predictions and analyses based on the moon’s position are more accurate. Vedic Astrology, in contrast to western astrology, can provide more concrete and detail-oriented ways of prediction.
Planets, signs, and houses are used in both Vedic and Western astrology to produce the chart. Vedic astrology, on the other hand, takes into account “Because it depicts the sign that was rising on the eastern horizon at the precise moment you were born, you” to be the rising sign. This is more precise than using a calculator “In Western astrology, “sun sign” is employed to prepare your chart. The reason we say this is because the sun has been in the same sign for the past 30 days. Your rising sign, on the other hand, was thought to be the exact minute on the day you were born. When it comes to making an astrology chart, the sun is undeniably significant, but so are the other planets, particularly the moon.
Vedic astrology encompasses astrological gemology, color therapy, mantra therapy, and a slew of other techniques for counteracting the harmful effects of the planets in our life. Western Astrology does not provide such a solution, which is one of the main reasons why western systems cannot match Vedic Astrology’s immense power.
Western astrology focuses on assessing an individual’s psychological nature, although it is ineffective at predicting future events. Vedic astrology, on the other hand, produces more predictable outcomes when it comes to predicting when specific events would occur. Vedic astrology is founded on karma, therefore it accurately describes an individual’s karmic tendencies and when they can be developed to that individual’s benefit. In western astrology, there is no technique for using karma to reap future advantages.
Yearly Vedic astrology predictions are more accurate and reliable than Western astrology predictions. All of these forecasts based on signs are generic. In western astrology, the sun sign is used to predict the year, therefore all people born in the same month are assigned to the same sun sign. They would be inheriting a certain set of traits. However, when utilizing moon signs to make a yearly prediction, two people born in the same month but at different times may have distinct birth stars. This is why Vedic astrology forecasts are more accurate.
You may have questioned why, according to Western astrology, your Sun sign is Aries, but in the Vedic system, it is Cancer. You may also notice differences in your rising sign and the placement of other planets in new signs. This occurs because a horoscope is calculated differently in Vedic and Western astrology. Both employ distinct methodologies to make predictions about a person’s nature, conduct, life events, and major events. Because the Western system is based on the Sun, it is superior at assessing physical and psychological patterns. Because it is based on the lunar system, which has a stable constellation, the Vedic system is considerably better at explaining the soul nature and predicting future occurrences.
Another advantage of the Vedic method over the Western system is that it employs the Dasa Predictive System. Depending on the planet, a planetary Dasa can last anywhere from 6 to 20 years. Vedic astrology not only assesses the circumstance, but also calculates the outcome of karma and offers a remedy to mitigate the bad effects of planets ruling your home. Thus, the Vedic system is more accurate because it has remained intact for thousands of years, and its base is the knowledge employed in modern astronomy with reference to any astronomical phenomena that occur inside the system. Let us be proud of our Vedic system!
What is the significance of sidereal astrology?
To summarize, we began with the sidereal Zodiac and fixed stars, and we will likely return there in the future. When there are strong alignments between the planets and fixed stars, the sidereal Zodiac makes perfect sense at this time. In comparison to the sidereal Zodiac, the tropical Zodiac is “closer to the Earth” and hence has a more direct influence.
The effect and astrological interpretation of the fixed stars is a fascinating topic, and a tale on their influence and astrological interpretation will be coming soon, so stay tuned!
The effect and astrological interpretation of the fixed stars is a fascinating topic, and more tales on the influence and astrological interpretation of the fixed stars will undoubtedly be coming soon, so stay tuned!
What makes sidereal astrology unique?
Sidereal uses a correcting system of equations called ayanamsas to more precisely identify the current location of each zodiac sign in order to account for this procession. The tropical system is dominant in part because humans are lazy and math is difficult. The Lahiri ayanamsa is the most extensively used of these equations. The Sidereal Zodiac acknowledges an apparent retrograde movement of fixed stars of around 1 degree every 72 years under this corrective. As a result, the tropical and sidereal systems are separated by 24 degrees, approximately a full zodiac sign.
Because of the differences between the tropical and sidereal systems, an individual’s birth chart will differ depending on which system is used. While the dates of the many zodiac signs vary depending on the system, their traits and effect are very similar. You can use an online sidereal calculator like this to get your sidereal sign and birth chart.
Planetary rulership and influence are another significant difference between tropical and sidereal astrology. Unlike tropical astrology, sidereal astrology does not take into account the influence of Uranus, Neptune, or Pluto on a person or their birth chart. These distant planets are invisible to the naked eye, and their far from Earth reduces their impact on life on the planet.